Microsoft ended support for the web browser you are using. Please use a modern web browser such as: Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge.

  • My Account
  • Sign In
  • Compare Products
  • Welcome,
  • Scan to Cart
  • My Reorder Pad
  • My Wish List  
Toggle Nav
My Cart
My Account
Search
Menu
Account

Nostalgia Candy | Nassau Candy

Nostalgia

Nostalgic and old-fashioned candy selections include “penny” candies, old school soda pop, hard-to-find vintage candy brands and cool retro products like Pop Rocks, Astro Pops, and Clark Bars. These time-tested favorites have delighted customers for generations.

Items 129-192 of 221

Set Descending Direction
  1. GILLIAM TUTTI FRUTTI STICK CANDY
    2627
    in Cart

    GILLIAM TUTTI FRUTTI STICK CANDY

  2. GILLIAM WATERMELON STICK CANDY
    2629
    in Cart

    GILLIAM WATERMELON STICK CANDY

  3. GOETZE'S CARAMEL BROWNIE
    23215
    in Cart

    GOETZE'S CARAMEL BROWNIE

  4. GOETZE'S CARAMEL CREAMS 1.9 OZ TRAY PACK
    10715
    in Cart

    GOETZE'S CARAMEL CREAMS 1.9 OZ TRAY PACK

  5. GOLD MINE GUM GIANT NUGGETS 8.82 OZ
    38393
    in Cart

    GOLD MINE GUM GIANT NUGGETS 8.82 OZ

  6. GOLD MINE GUM NUGGETS 2 OZ POUCH
    3059
    in Cart

    GOLD MINE GUM NUGGETS 2 OZ POUCH

  7. GOLDENBERG'S ORIGINAL DARK CHOCOLATE PEANUT CHEWS 2 OZ
    12971
    in Cart

    GOLDENBERG'S ORIGINAL DARK CHOCOLATE PEANUT CHEWS 2 OZ

  8. GOLDENBERG'S ORIGINAL DARK CHOCOLATE PEANUT CHEWS 3.3 OZ
    24123
    in Cart

    GOLDENBERG'S ORIGINAL DARK CHOCOLATE PEANUT CHEWS 3.3 OZ

  9. GOO GOO CLUSTER ORIGINAL 1.75 OZ
    25561
    in Cart

    GOO GOO CLUSTER ORIGINAL 1.75 OZ

  10. GOO GOO CLUSTER PEANUT BUTTER 1.5 OZ
    25563
    in Cart

    GOO GOO CLUSTER PEANUT BUTTER 1.5 OZ

  11. GOO GOO CLUSTER PECAN 1.5 OZ
    25562
    in Cart

    GOO GOO CLUSTER PECAN 1.5 OZ

  12. GOOD & PLENTY
    714
    in Cart

    GOOD & PLENTY

  13. GOOD & PLENTY 6 OZ THEATER BOX
    11220
    in Cart

    GOOD & PLENTY 6 OZ THEATER BOX

  14. GUMMY BAND AIDS
    5616
    in Cart

    GUMMY BAND AIDS

  15. HARIBO ROULETTE GUMMY CANDY 0.88 OZ
    989253
    in Cart

    HARIBO ROULETTE GUMMY CANDY 0.88 OZ

  16. HERSHEY'S NOSTALGIC MILK CHOCOLATE 3.5 OZ BAR
    28333
    in Cart

    HERSHEY'S NOSTALGIC MILK CHOCOLATE 3.5 OZ BAR

  17. HERSHEY'S NOSTALGIC MILK CHOCOLATE WITH ALMONDS 3.5 OZ BAR
    28334
    in Cart

    HERSHEY'S NOSTALGIC MILK CHOCOLATE WITH ALMONDS 3.5 OZ BAR

  18. HOT TAMALES
    792
    in Cart

    HOT TAMALES

  19. ICE CUBES ICE CHOCOLATE
    831
    in Cart

    ICE CUBES ICE CHOCOLATE

  20. IDAHO SPUD 1.5 OZ BAR
    24180
    in Cart

    IDAHO SPUD 1.5 OZ BAR

  21. JACKSON HOLE BUCKIN' ROOT BEER 12 OZ BOTTLE
    951983
    in Cart

    JACKSON HOLE BUCKIN' ROOT BEER 12 OZ BOTTLE

  22. JACKSON HOLE HIGH MOUNTAIN HUCKLEBERRY SODA 12 OZ BOTTLE
    951984
    in Cart

    JACKSON HOLE HIGH MOUNTAIN HUCKLEBERRY SODA 12 OZ BOTTLE

  23. JOLLY RANCHER ASSORTED
    536A
    in Cart

    JOLLY RANCHER ASSORTED

  24. JOYVA JOYS CHOCOLATE COVERED RASPBERRY JELLE 1.5 OZ BAR
    JB36
    in Cart

    JOYVA JOYS CHOCOLATE COVERED RASPBERRY JELLE 1.5 OZ BAR

  25. JUJU CHERRY COINS
    748
    in Cart

    JUJU CHERRY COINS

  26. JUJUBES 5.5 OZ THEATER BOX
    25645
    in Cart

    JUJUBES 5.5 OZ THEATER BOX

  27. JUJYFRUITS 5 OZ THEATER BOX
    6971
    in Cart

    JUJYFRUITS 5 OZ THEATER BOX

  28. JUNIOR MINTS 1.84 OZ
    JRM
    in Cart

    JUNIOR MINTS 1.84 OZ

  29. LA PIPETTE CANDY PIPES BLACK LICORICE
    KB20650
    in Cart

    LA PIPETTE CANDY PIPES BLACK LICORICE

  30. LAFFY TAFFY ROPE SOUR APPLE
    15761
    in Cart

    LAFFY TAFFY ROPE SOUR APPLE

  31. LAFFY TAFFY ROPES BANANA 24 COUNT
    15760
    in Cart

    LAFFY TAFFY ROPES BANANA 24 COUNT

  32. LAFFY TAFFY ROPES BLUE RASPBERRY 24 COUNT
    15763
    in Cart

    LAFFY TAFFY ROPES BLUE RASPBERRY 24 COUNT

  33. LAFFY TAFFY ROPES CHERRY 24 COUNT
    15762
    in Cart

    LAFFY TAFFY ROPES CHERRY 24 COUNT

  34. LAFFY TAFFY ROPES STRAWBERRY 24 COUNT
    15759
    in Cart

    LAFFY TAFFY ROPES STRAWBERRY 24 COUNT

  35. LEMONHEAD WRAPPED
    22053
    in Cart

    LEMONHEAD WRAPPED

  36. LICORICE CATS
    9654
    in Cart

    LICORICE CATS

  37. MAGIC COLOR BUBBLEGUM CIGARETTES 0.96 OZ
    W410
    in Cart

    MAGIC COLOR BUBBLEGUM CIGARETTES 0.96 OZ

  38. MALLO CUPS MILK CHOCOLATE 1.6 OZ
    13484
    in Cart

    MALLO CUPS MILK CHOCOLATE 1.6 OZ

  39. MAMBA ORIGINAL 2.8 OZ STICK
    23106
    in Cart

    MAMBA ORIGINAL 2.8 OZ STICK

  40. MARY JANE
    606
    in Cart

    MARY JANE

  41. MCCRAW'S GIANT TAFFY 0.75 OZ
    1552
    in Cart

    MCCRAW'S GIANT TAFFY 0.75 OZ

  42. MEGA CANDY BUTTONS 3 OZ
    22459
    in Cart

    MEGA CANDY BUTTONS 3 OZ

  43. MIKE AND IKE ORIGINAL
    795
    in Cart

    MIKE AND IKE ORIGINAL

  44. MILK CHOCOLATE BAND AIDS 2.7 OZ BOX
    LE511
    in Cart

    MILK CHOCOLATE BAND AIDS 2.7 OZ BOX

  45. MILK DUDS 5 OZ THEATER BOX
    11219
    in Cart

    MILK DUDS 5 OZ THEATER BOX

  46. MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER BANANA 2.75 OZ
    42606
    in Cart

    MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER BANANA 2.75 OZ

  47. MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER CHOCOLATE 2.75 OZ
    42603
    in Cart

    MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER CHOCOLATE 2.75 OZ

  48. MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER SEA SALT CARAMEL 2.75 OZ
    42605
    in Cart

    MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER SEA SALT CARAMEL 2.75 OZ

  49. MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER STRAWBERRY 2.75 OZ
    45217
    in Cart

    MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER STRAWBERRY 2.75 OZ

  50. MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER VANILLA 2.75 OZ
    42604
    in Cart

    MOON PIE DOUBLE DECKER VANILLA 2.75 OZ

  51. MOXIE SODA ORIGINAL ELIXIR 12 OZ BOTTLE
    951976
    in Cart

    MOXIE SODA ORIGINAL ELIXIR 12 OZ BOTTLE

  52. MUNCH PEANUT BAR 1.42 OZ
    22189
    in Cart

    MUNCH PEANUT BAR 1.42 OZ

  53. NECCO CHOCOLATE WAFERS 2.02 OZ ROLL
    23009
    in Cart

    NECCO CHOCOLATE WAFERS 2.02 OZ ROLL

  54. NECCO ORIGINAL CANDY WAFERS 2 OZ ROLL
    23010
    in Cart

    NECCO ORIGINAL CANDY WAFERS 2 OZ ROLL

  55. NIK L NIP MINI DRINKS 4 PACK
    20231
    in Cart

    NIK L NIP MINI DRINKS 4 PACK

  56. NIK L NIP MINI DRINKS 8 PACK 0.19 OZ
    21152
    in Cart

    NIK L NIP MINI DRINKS 8 PACK 0.19 OZ

  57. PEARSON'S MAPLE BUN BAR 1.75 OZ
    27939
    in Cart

    PEARSON'S MAPLE BUN BAR 1.75 OZ

  58. PEARSON'S NUT GOODIES 1.75 OZ
    27938
    in Cart

    PEARSON'S NUT GOODIES 1.75 OZ

  59. PEARSON'S SALTED NUT ROLL 1.8 OZ
    22844
    in Cart

    PEARSON'S SALTED NUT ROLL 1.8 OZ

  60. PEARSON'S VANILLA BUN BAR 1.75 OZ
    27940
    in Cart

    PEARSON'S VANILLA BUN BAR 1.75 OZ

  61. PEPPERMINT PUFFS WRAPPED
    11757
    in Cart

    PEPPERMINT PUFFS WRAPPED

  62. PEZ REFILL 8 PC BLISTER PACK
    24134
    in Cart

    PEZ REFILL 8 PC BLISTER PACK

  63. PIXY STIX
    S11581
    in Cart

    PIXY STIX

  64. RAZZLES ORIGINAL FLAVORS 1.4 OZ BAG
    RAZ
    in Cart

    RAZZLES ORIGINAL FLAVORS 1.4 OZ BAG

Page
per page

Filter By

Shopping Options

Category

Priced By

Occasion

Manufactured

Brand

Packaging

Flavor

Color

Nutrition Claims

Certifications

Kosher

Refrigerated

Region

Shopping Highlights

My Wish List
Loading...
total
Last Added Items...
Go to Wish List
You have no items in your wish list.